The Comparison Trap: How I Stopped Buying Things to Match Other People's Feeds

Published
Category
Budget
The Comparison Trap: How I Stopped Buying Things to Match Other People's Feeds
Written by
Mason Rios profile picture

Mason Rios, Senior Finance Strategist

Former spreadsheet-obsessed CPA turned everyday finance translator. Mason has worked with solo entrepreneurs and side-hustlers for over a decade and now writes to make budgeting feel less like punishment and more like permission. When he’s not writing, he’s testing out budgeting apps and debunking myths about “frivolous spending.”

There was a time when I’d open Instagram or scroll through LinkedIn, see someone’s “new minimalist office setup” or “investment watch of the moment,” and immediately feel a pull. Not envy, exactly—but something close. More like the quiet suggestion that I needed to upgrade or improve in some visible way.

And as a financial strategist, I should have known better. I do know better. I’ve spent years advising clients on how to build wealth intentionally. Still, the comparison trap can get to anyone. Social media thrives on the subtle (and sometimes not-so-subtle) highlight reel, and without realizing it, I found myself spending time to match lifestyles that weren’t even mine.

So I did what I’d advise any client to do—I stepped back, examined my behavior, and started redesigning my spending from a place of clarity instead of comparison. This isn’t a story of total minimalism or self-deprivation. It’s about strategy, awareness, and value-driven decisions.

Let me walk you through how I got out of the trap, and how you might too.

Let’s Name the Trap

What we’re talking about has a name in behavioral finance: social comparison theory. It’s the human tendency to assess our worth, success, or satisfaction based on how we stack up against others. And in today’s world, we’re bombarded with comparisons 24/7.

Visuals 1 (25).png

It’s not hard to see why—when your feed is a curated carousel of designer bags, luxury travel, home makeovers, and "quiet luxury" aesthetics, it’s easy to believe you’re falling behind.

But here’s the truth: most of what we see online isn’t financially transparent. You rarely see the credit card debt, the overextended budgets, or the internal pressure fueling those purchases. You just see the polished outcome. And that disconnect leads many people to make decisions that hurt their financial future—just to feel like they’re keeping up today.

The Real Cost: It’s Not Just the Price Tag

When we talk about financial planning, we tend to think in numbers—how much you earn, spend, save, or invest. But the comparison trap introduces non-financial costs that slowly chip away at your progress.

Here’s what I’ve seen in both my life and in countless client conversations:

  • Delayed financial goals: People redirect money from retirement, emergency funds, or investments to fund lifestyle inflation.
  • Debt accumulation: Using “buy now, pay later” or credit cards to afford status-driven purchases.
  • Emotional burnout: Feeling like no matter how well you’re doing, it’s not enough because someone else appears to be doing better.

None of these things feel huge in isolation. But collectively? They can stall your financial momentum for years. And the worst part? You might not even realize you're doing it until your savings accounts (or your mental health) reflect the damage.

So, What Helped Me Break the Pattern?

It wasn’t about deleting social media or suddenly rejecting everything stylish. It was about rewiring the why behind my spending—and letting go of the need to "signal" success.

Here’s what actually made a lasting difference:

1. I Created a Personal Spending Philosophy

Instead of cutting back reactively, I took time to define what spending felt good—and what didn’t.

I started asking myself: What purchases bring real utility or joy? Where does my money make my life easier, more meaningful, or more aligned with my values?

For example, I realized I love spending on:

  • Tools or tech that streamline my work
  • Travel that lets me unplug and reset
  • Gifts or experiences shared with family

But things like upgrading my wardrobe every season or buying expensive décor for “aesthetic” reasons? That never left me feeling better for long.

So I wrote a short spending filter. Before any non-essential purchase, I ask myself:

  • Am I buying this for me, or for others to see?
  • Will I care about this a month from now?
  • Is there a version of this that costs less but gives me the same benefit?

That filter alone has probably saved me thousands.

2. I Separated Influence from Intent

Social media isn’t inherently bad. It can inspire, inform, and even spark creativity. But I had to start noticing how it was influencing me.

If I saw a post and immediately wanted to buy something, I didn’t click “add to cart.” Instead, I saved it to a folder titled “Circle Back Later.” I gave it a 48-hour buffer.

More often than not, I didn’t return. If I did, I had time to assess whether it was a passing impulse or a genuine want.

This helped retrain my brain to pause between trigger and action. That pause is everything.

3. I Reframed Success Without the Props

As a finance professional, I’ve seen people with seven-figure portfolios who live modestly—and others who appear wealthy but are deeply in debt.

The external markers we associate with success—cars, clothes, tech, vacations—are often just that: markers. They don’t always reflect financial health.

So I started measuring success differently:

  • Am I growing my net worth?
  • Do I have financial flexibility?
  • Can I make choices based on values, not paycheck cycles?

When success became about freedom instead of appearances, I stopped needing so many props to prove it.

4. I Tracked My Progress Instead of Their Purchases

The best antidote to comparison is focus. And that meant turning inward.

I built a simple system for tracking my net worth, monthly savings rate, and financial milestones. I checked in every month—not obsessively, but intentionally.

This gave me a positive feedback loop that social media couldn’t offer. Instead of thinking “They bought a new car,” I’d think, “I just hit 30% of my annual investment goal.”

When you measure the right things, external noise starts to fade.

Money peer pressure is real—31% of Americans admit they’ve felt it, according to LendingTree. For millennials, that feeling is even stronger, with 41% saying they’ve struggled to keep up with friends’ spending.

Why This Isn’t About Deprivation

Let’s be clear—this isn’t a call to spend nothing, own nothing, or disengage from the world. I’m not anti-luxury or anti-nice-things. I’m just pro-intention.

The goal isn’t to deny yourself. It’s to stop letting the internet’s highlight reel dictate your financial choices. When you align spending with what actually matters to you, you don’t feel deprived—you feel in control.

And that sense of control? It’s what gives you peace, confidence, and the freedom to live well on your own terms.

4 Smart Moves

  • Build a "Waitlist" Folder: Instead of impulse buying, save screenshots or links for 48 hours. If it still feels right, revisit with clarity.
  • Set Spending Priorities, Not Budgets: Assign values to categories that matter most to you (e.g., travel > tech upgrades). Let your money reflect that.
  • Unfollow or Mute Accounts That Trigger FOMO: It’s not personal. It’s just smart boundary-setting for your financial health.
  • Track Net Worth Monthly: Even if it's just in a simple spreadsheet, watching your own progress replaces the urge to compare.

Real Wealth Isn’t for Show

Here’s what I know after decades in finance: The wealthiest, most financially confident people I’ve worked with don’t show it off. They don’t need to. Their peace comes from knowing they’re secure, not from proving anything online.

Getting out of the comparison trap isn’t just a money move—it’s a mindset shift. It means deciding that your financial goals are valid, even if they don’t look impressive on a feed. It means trusting your pace, your path, and your priorities.

And most importantly, it means spending your money in ways that support your life—not someone else’s aesthetic.

Because when you stop buying to impress people you don’t even know, you finally start building a life that impresses you.

Was this article helpful? Let us know!